Parliamentary Inspection and Legislation Trend

Beginning with speeches by representatives from various negotiating groups on October 7, the 20-day parliamentary inspections opened on October 14. Following the parliamentary inspection, interpellation sessions as well as deliberation on budget/legislative bills are scheduled.

[Table 1] 320th Parliamentary regular session & agenda

Regular Session Schedule
Remarks
Date
Agenda
Sep. 30 (Mon.)
‣ Adoption of the report on investigation for
normalization of public medical services
‣ Extending the term of Special Committees
Standing Committee activities
Oct. 2 (Wed.) ~ 4 (Fri.)
Oct. 1 (Tue.)
‣ Questions on urgent matters
Oct. 7 (Mon.)~
Oct. 8 (Tue.)
‣ Speeches by representatives of
negotiation groups
Oct. 10 (Thu.)
‣ Approval of institutions subject to Inspection of State Administration (ISA) that require resolution at a plenary session
Oct. 14 (Mon.)~
Nov. 10 (Sat.)
(20 days)
‣ Parliamentary inspections
Nov. 4 (Mon.)
‣ Speech by the government on the budget
bill and the fund operation plan for 2014
Standing Committee activities
Nov. 5 (Tue.) ~ 7 (Thu.)
Nov. 8 (Fri.)
‣ Settlement of Accounts for fiscal year 2012
Nov. 11 (Mon.)~
Nov. 15 (Fri.)
(5 days)
‣ Parliamentary Interpellation Sessions
Nov. 11 (Mon.)        Politics
Nov. 12 (Tue.)         Diplomacy, Unification and Security
Nov. 13 (Wed.)        Economy
Nov. 15 (Thu.)         Economy (continued)
Nov. 15 (Fri.)            Education, Society and Culture
Nov. 21 (Thu.), Nov. 28 (Thu.), Dec. 2 (Mon.),  Dec. 9 (Mon.),  Dec. 10 (Tue.)
‣ Handling of agendas
Standing Committee activities
Nov. 22 (Fri.)~27 (Wed.)/Dec. 3 (Tue.)~6 (Fri.)

 

Labor-related bills

As of October 23, a total of 293 labor-related bills were presented to the Environment & Labor Committee of the 19th National Assembly. Of those, 10 (of 278) bills proposed by lawmakers and 2 (of 15 bills) from the government have been passed at the plenary session.


[Table 2] Pending labor-related bills during the 19th National Assembly (as of Oct. 23)

Total
Environmental and Labor Committee
Pending at  Legislation and Judiciary Committee
Passed at the plenary session
Repealed
Sub-total
Submitted
Sub-committee
Total
314
283
103
180
2
12
17
Proposed by lawmakers
299
272
103
169
1
(Act on the Protection etc.,of Dispatched Workers)
10
16
Proposed by the government
15
11
0
11
1
(Basic Workers Welfare Act)
2
1

 

Trends and Prospects for Legislation

1. Reduction of working hours

The government shares the view with the ruling and opposition parties that holiday work should be included in “extended work”; however, they are divided over the issues such as enforcement timing, exceptions allowing extended work, adjustment of the exempted industries list, etc.


[Table 3] Major legislative issues on reduction of working hours

Issues
Ruling Party
Opposition Parties
Time of enforcement
‣ Gradual enforcement based on company size
‣ Immediate and
comprehensive enforcement
Exceptions
‣ For exceptions, allow an additional 8-hour extended work
Adjustment of the list of exempted industries
‣ 26 → 10 industries
‣ Abolish the list
Expanding the unit of flexible working hours
‣ 2 weeks → 1 month
‣ 3months→ 6 months or 1 year

 

2. Restrictions on dismissal for managerial reasons

Both the ruling and opposition parties have proposed similar bills on this issue. Whereas the opposition parties have expressed their intention to accept the ruling party’s views regarding this issue at the Environment & Labor Committee’s Legislative Review Sub-committee on June 20, within the government and the ruling party, there are voices claiming that some adjustments to the bill need to be made.


[Table 4] Major legislative issues regarding managerial dismissal

Issues
Ruling & Opposition Parties
Managerial requirements
‣  Only in situations where employers cannot continue to do business, dismissal for managerial reasons can be justified
Efforts to avoid dismissal
‣  If an employer does not make every effort to avoid dismissal, dismissal for managerial reasons is not justified
Preferential
re-employment
‣ Employers shall preferentially re-employ former employees engaged in the same or similar kinds of work in the business or workplace concerned

 

3. Expanding the scope of “ordinary wage”

When the ruling of the Supreme Court comes out, the ruling party and the government plan to take a legal action based on consultation with labor and management. However, some labor including the Federation of Korean Trade Unions (FKTU) is refusing to join the dialogue. In the meantime, opposition parties have already presented a revision bill to expand the scope of “ordinary wage”.


[Table 5] Major legislative issues surrounding “Ordinary Wage”

Ruling Party
Opposition Parties
‣ “Ordinary wage” refers to wages in cash or other valuables which are determined to be paid to an employee
‣  Any wages paid for a period exceeding one month, or paid to a certain group of employees


4. Protection of in-house subcontract workers

While the ruling party is trying to push for the bill on protection of in-house contracted workers, opposition parties are opposed to the legislation, demanding prohibition of indirect employment within partner firms in the service sector.


[Table 6] Major legislative issues regarding in-house subcontract workers and other indirect employment

Ruling Party
Opposition Parties
Act on the protection of in-house subcontracted workers
Labor Standards Act, Act on the protection, etc., of dispatched workers
‣  Grant trade unions a right to file a complaint on behalf of workers to rectify discrimination
‣ Introduce punitive monetary compensation
‣  In case a contractor is changed, the primary employer has a responsibility to maintain the existing working conditions
‣  If there is a liability of the primary employer, hold the primary employer joint responsibility for the payment of wages to in-house subcontract employees
‣ Prohibit indirect employment for regular job positions. In case of violation of the Act, directly employ
‣ In case a contractor is changed, the new contractor should be responsible to maintain the existing employees’ rights and obligations
‣ Stipulate clearly the criteria for “contracted work” and “dispatched work”

 

5. Strengthening regulations on non-regular workers

The bill regarding the public announcement of employment types and the bill prohibiting discrimination (in terms of bonuses) against non-regular workers, were passed at the National Assembly in November 2012 and February 2013 respectively.

Following these bills, in the extraordinary session of the National Assembly, more regulations on non-regular workers, such as a strong correction order for discrimination and punitive monetary compensation of up to 10 times the amount of damages, were passed by the Environment & Labor Committee this April. As a result, regulations on non-regular workers seem to be getting stronger.

 

[Table 7] Major legislative issues regarding non-regular workers

Issues
Ruling Party
Opposition Parties
Restriction on use of non-regular workers
Allow the use of non-regular workers only for labor shortages and for seasonal or temporary projects
Right to file a discrimination complaint
Grant trade unions a right, on behalf of employees, to file
complaints to rectify discrimination
Punitive compensation
In case of intended and repeated discrimination against non-regular workers, order
compensation of up to 10 times the amount of damages
Strengthen the scope of correction orders
Apply a correction order to all employees working under the same conditions

 

6. Legislative protection for independent workers

On November 21, 2012, at the Environment & Labor Committee’s Legislative Review Sub-committee, the ruling party proposed that independent workers should be recognized as “employees” according to labor law.

Thereafter, the ruling party retreated from its earlier stance, saying that agreement between labor, management and the government needed to be reached in advance on this issue. The opposition parties also echoed the ruling party’s view regarding the legal status of independent workers. The government, however, is trying to address this issue by revising the Labor Relations Commission Act.

 

[Table 8] Main points of the revised bill on independent workers

Main Points
Government
Ruling Party
Opposition Parties
Labor Relations Commission Act
▸ Prepare systems for dispute resolution
Act on the Collection, etc., of Premiums for Employment Insurance and Industrial Accident Compensation Insurance
▸ The government should cover up to 50% of industrial accident premiums
Labor Standards Act, Trade Union and Labor Relations Adjustment Act
▸ Recognize independent workers as “employees”


7. Strengthening industrial safety regulations

The government and ruling party are planning to relax the requirements of the enforcement decrees of the Act on Registration and Evaluation, etc. of Chemical Substances and the Korean Toxic Chemicals Control Act. The government is also planning to enhance industrial safety inspections of workplaces.

On the other hand, the opposition parties are expected to work on legislation of the revised bill for the Occupational Safety & Health Act, which forbids subcontracting of harmful work in the 2nd half of 2013. The opposition parties attempted legislation of the revised bill during the 1st half of 2013 but were not successful.

 

[Table 9] Main points of revised bill for the Occupational Safety & Health Act

Ruling Party
Opposition Parties
▸ Open process safety report to neighborhood residents
▸ Include emotional workers in the scope of protected occupations under the Occupational Safety & Health Act
▸ Prohibit subcontracting of harmful and dangerous work
▸ Strengthen the penalty for primary
 contractors if they violate their obligations.
▸ Include service industry in the industrial accident prevention program for primary contractors.

8. Legal issues regarding minimum wage

Both the ruling and opposition parties have proposed bills to increase the minimum wage, but specific measures are pending in the National Assembly due to differing opinions on setup of lower limits etc.

[Table 10] Main points of the revised bill for the Minimum Wage Act

Issues
Main Points
Ruling Party
Opposition Parties
Criteria for determining minimum wage
▸ Reflect economic growth · inflation
▸ Set the lower limit at 50% of the
average fixed wage.
Arbiter of minimum wage
▸ The National Assembly determines
the minimum wage, or the Minimum Wage Council determines the wage, taking into consideration the recommendations of the National Assembly.
Exclusion from application of minimum wage
▸ Abolish the regulation allowing a
reduced minimum wage for apprentices or intermittent · surveillance workers.

 

9. Time-off system and multiple unions system

Amidst the opposition parties’ continuous demands for revision of the law, the government and ruling party are insisting on improvement rather than abolishment of the existing laws. However, close attention to the issue is still required since some within the ruling party have proposed a bill to exclude supra-enterprise-level unions from the requirement to have a unified bargaining channel.


[Table 11] Main points of the revised bill for the Trade Union &Labor Relations Adjustment Act

Issues
Main Points
Ruling Party
Opposition Parties
Time-off
▸ Abolish the regulation to punish employers who pay wages to full-time union officers
▸ When trade unions dispatch their officers to upper-level organizations, the hours of dispatch should be included in the time-off limit
▸ Abolish time-off system
Multiple unions system
▸ Expand exclusions from the requirement to have a unified bargaining channel
(For bargaining at the industry level or agreements between labor and management, with agreement from employers)
▸ Abolish the requirement to unify bargaining channel

 10. Part-time jobs

As part of its roadmap to achieve a 70% employment rate, the government is planning to legislate, within this year, the ‘Act on protection of part-time workers and employment promotion’ which focuses on eliminating discrimination between full-time and part-time workers and grant the right to demand reduced working hours. However, difficulties are expected since the opposition parties, as well as some members of the ruling party are against it.


Parliamentary inspection
 
Standing Committees under the National Assembly decided on witnesses for the 2013 parliamentary inspections (Oct. 14 ~ Nov. 2). The 7 major committees chose a total of 419 witnesses, 228 of whom are from private companies and organizations (the largest number for the past 3 years).

[Table 12] Witnesses as chosen by the 7 major standing committees
2011 (18th National Assembly)
2012 (19th National Assembly)
2013 (19th National Assembly)
Non-expert witnesses (reference)
Witnesses from private companies/or-ganization
(reference)
Non-expert witnesses (reference)
Witnesses from private companies/or-ganization
(reference)
Non-expert witnesses (reference)
Witnesses from private companies/or-ganization
(reference)
144
(73)
80
(25)
224
(106)
164
(12)
285
(134)
202
(26)
* The 7 major Standing Committees: the National Policy Committee; the Trade, Industry & Energy Committee; the Strategy & Finance Committee; the Science, ICT & Future Planning; Broadcasting & Communications Committee; the Land, Infrastructure & Transport Committee; the Health & Welfare Committee; and the Environment & Labor Committee.

The Environment & Labor Committee confirmed the summoning of 59 witnesses for the plenary session on October 7th, while labor is planning to solve current labor issues such as illegal dispatch by making them political issues.
On October 14th, the Environment & Labor Committee began its inspection of the Ministry of Employment & Labor (MOEL) and related institutes. By summoning many businessmen, some politicians tried to make individual workplace issues political issues such as the layoffs at Ssangyong Motor Company, accidents at Hyundai Steel, and allegations that workers were illegally dispatched to Samsung Electronics’ Service (SES). The Democratic Party stated that the labor inspections were a failure and the government inspected the whole workplace at Hyundai Motors for illegal dispatch situations, but only implemented a partial inspection on the subcontractor companies of SES, as per the request of SES.
In relation to the reinstatement of dismissed workers at Ssangyong Motors, the Environment & Labor Committee requested that the company put its best efforts into bringing the workers back. Ssangyong Motor CEO, Mr. Yoo-il Lee, stated that the company would follow the Court’s ruling. At present, labor and management at Ssangyong Motors are planning to form a Task Force to discuss production and sales targets for 2014, introduction of a daytime two-shift system, and hiring more workers for the new shift.